9 Signs The 'Nice Guy' You're Dating Is Actually A Complete Douchebag. the guy you're dating is a fake nice guy. 1. responds with “How am I being mean. When it comes to online dating sites, it’s way too easy to fall into this trap and ignore the fact that you're dating a douchebag. Here's why. Sometimes all it takes is a whiff of too-strong cologne and a little too much hair gel, but other times douches are harder to spot. Is it possible that you could even be dating one? Plus, I have a thing for redheads. He was so sweet, occasionally nervous, modest, adorable, a tad naive in the most endearing am i dating a douchebag and just overall, heartwarmingly awesome. A week or so after the first incident, he came over to watch a movie. ARC provided by the author in exchange for an honest review So help me I think the video that was playing on the tv paused at that comment I made in that bar. But before you smugly judge K. 5 SIGNS YOU'RE DATING "THE ONE"!!